Comparison14 replies

Torn between the Scala and the Corolla.

Translated from Turkish
Original Poster

I have a 1-1.3M budget. I'm torn between a 2022 Skoda 1.0 Premium with 70,000 km and a 2021 Corolla 1.5 Dream with 90,000 km. Could anyone who's driven them write about their experience? Or is there a different suggestion? Space and fuel matter.

Translated from Turkish

Replies

14 replies

It'd be a 2019-2020 model, but it'll be reliable. You could look at the Civic 1.6i Dtec diesel automatic. Around 1.3 [million]

Translated from Turkish

That would be my choice too, but I couldn't find a Civic under 150,000 km. Thanks for the suggestion.

Translated from Turkish

I'm driving a Scala, 1.6 TDI, 2020 model, currently around 145k km. It's one of the first ones that came to Turkey, an ex-fleet car despite that, still no vibration from the DSG, I'd say it's good in terms of durability. Fuel consumption is quite good, in calm driving it's around 4.5 liters, and depending on the situation it can drop down to 3 liters. I've also ridden in the Corolla a lot because of my friends - if you don't do much highway driving it could work, maybe, but I'd recommend the Scala. In terms of space, even though it's a hatchback, it's quite sufficient.

Translated from Turkish

To make a full comparison: if the Corolla is a hybrid, fuel consumption in the city is very good, and ACC and lane-keeping systems are available, though they're usually optional and not included on base gasoline trims. On the Scala, unless you're buying a very new or 0 km one, these features aren't there, though they can of course be added afterward. Specifically for lane-keeping, comfort and quietness, the Corolla is quite noisy on the highway, the Scala is quite good in this regard. In terms of suspension they're almost the same.

Translated from Turkish

In terms of fuel, the gasoline Corolla burns a lot, the hybrid is quite good especially in the city but not that great on the highway. The Scala is quite nice, my long-term city average is around 5.5, and on the highway with calm driving I've made it from Eskişehir to Ankara on 3.3 liters. As for chronic issues, there's nothing wrong with the gasoline Corollas; hybrid batteries become less efficient at 100-150k [km] and might need replacing. Maybe the Scala's DSG, but I haven't heard of issues on the 1.6 TDIs. The one chronic thing that fails on the Scala is the SOS module.

Translated from Turkish

But it's not a very important fault, you can keep driving without getting it fixed. If you want to get it fixed, there are places in the industrial area that do it for around 10 [thousand], the price at the dealer service is a bit steep though.

Translated from Turkish

Both cars are 3-cylinder. In my opinion, TSI engines are the most trouble-free in this category. But engines with low displacement and high compression also tend to have shorter lifespans. For the Corolla 1.6 or the Scala 1.5 TSI, I find it more reasonable to look at slightly higher-mileage examples within the same budget. I have a 1.6 TDI Scala myself, I'm happy with it, but the DQ200 transmission is always a question mark, it could cost you money at any time. In short, if you want technology, Scala; if you want reliability, Corolla.

Translated from Turkish

Thanks a lot for the comments, guys. I got a 2023 Taigo 1.0 Life. Let's see if I'll regret it.

Translated from Turkish