Chat19 replies

German? or Japanese?

Translated from Turkish

Replies

19 replies

I've driven exactly two different, accessible cars fitting this question. I drove a 2018 Civic HB for about 100,000 km. Before that I drove an F20 116i for about 90,000 km. Right now I'm driving a 2013 F20 118i, 4-cylinder, 170hp again. The Japanese car's reliability is of course very good, it doesn't give you much of a headache, but if you're doing a lot of long trips, sometimes you end up looking for comfort and insulation more than that reliability. I can say for sure that the 2013 F20 is more comfortable and has better insulation than the 2018 FK7. Also, the trim rattles in the Civic are way too much

Translated from Turkish

It's a tough question, you could talk about it for hours. In short: it's entirely a matter of need and budget.

Translated from Turkish

If you drive a Mercedes, you can enjoy both comfort and reliability.

Translated from Turkish

I also think it's partly a budget matter — at budgets where German and Japanese are equal, I'd prefer Japanese, but when it comes to German's upper classes, it pulls ahead in every respect.

Translated from Turkish

I've driven VAG group cars for many years and still do, so out of reflex I'll say "German." Of course the Japanese have their legendary reliability too, but it's just habit :)

Translated from Turkish

The reliability of Japanese cars comes from there being nothing that can really break down — reliable. But when you get out of a German car and into a Japanese one, the cars feel flimsy, like paper.

Translated from Turkish

If you've driven a German car, a Japanese one might feel flimsy to you. Both have their own pros and cons. Also, German cars aren't that problematic — I've mostly driven German cars myself, and in the Japanese ones I've been in, I didn't even feel like opening and closing the door.

Translated from Turkish