雑談23 replies

Recommendations up to 2 million

トルコ語から翻訳
Original Poster

I have a max 2M budget; I'm thinking of a clean Tonale, but 2018 320ds with around 150k km also confuse me, and on the other hand the Superb is a nice car too. In short, I'm waiting for your recommendations and advice up to 2M

トルコ語から翻訳

Replies

23 replies · Page 1 of 2

The Tonale is currently one of the most sensible C-SUVs on the market. What you mentioned are D-segment cars. Expectations matter here - for example, some users have written that BMW's Harman Kardon sound system is better than the one in the Tonale. But it's also a fact that even though the Tonale is a nearly newer model, it's priced far more sensibly than a lot of its rivals. Think about it: for 2M you're getting a nearly new C-SUV with a sunroof, Harman Kardon, electric seats, heating/cooling, Brembo brakes, and a rock-solid design, etc.

トルコ語から翻訳

@alperenakman Yeah, it looks like my first choice will be the 1.6 Tonale. Are you happy with it? How's the quality and comfort? There are people saying it's no different from the Egea Cross and it's confusing me.

トルコ語から翻訳

Quality-wise it's very good, but there can be the typical Alfa chronic issue of trim noise - as a fix, people on forums have written that they use Wurth spray. Comfort-wise it varies from package to package - our old car was a Tiguan with 17-inch wheels. Our Tonale has 19-inch wheels, so naturally the car is a bit firmer. But I can't say it's a huge difference. But if you can afford it, I'd recommend getting the 1.5 hybrid - I've read people saying the 1.6 lacks power.

トルコ語から翻訳

I get why they compare this car to the Egea - Alfa Romeo is Fiat's after all. Back in the day people used to say the solid 159s had a Doblo engine, but for its era it was a rock-solid car. Even Mercedes uses Brembo brakes on some of its AMG models, and Alfa Romeo put them on a C-SUV :) I really like it, and I'd say it's built up its own little market. If you can find a nice one with the warranty still active, I recommend it. Over time the car proves its quality to its owner. At least that's how it went for us.

トルコ語から翻訳

@alperenakman My reason for preferring the 1.6 is that it's trouble-free - And Cetin said the 1.5s have chronic issues, and it's also written in some forums, but I couldn't find any info about the 1.3. I could also consider the 280hp plug-in, I'm just afraid it'll cause problems.

トルコ語から翻訳

As for the car, my old one was a Hyundai i30, now I'm driving a CHR - I think comfort and quality will improve.

トルコ語から翻訳

Mate, we have the 1.3, we bought it knowing full well there's no authorized service in our city. Well, I've read posts about these cars saying that both the 1.5s and the 1.3s went to the service center a lot in the first year, but afterward, once all the chronic issues were resolved, they ran without problems. For example, in our car's service history it went to the service center a few times in the first year, but since we've owned it, it's been running like a beast. Whichever model you get, make sure to check the car's service history through the Alfa Link app.

トルコ語から翻訳

Also if you live in Trabzon, there's an authorized service there, which is great. As for quality and comfort compared to the CH-R and i30, I haven't driven them so I can't say anything, but taking the wheel size difference into account, I can say it's a bit stiffer than the Tiguan. But it's better in terms of material quality. We have an active group about the Tonale on DonanımHaber, I'd recommend checking that out too.

トルコ語から翻訳

I live in Antalya, but there's an authorized service here too, so no problem there. If I get the 1.3, I'm not sure if I can manage without charging at home, just using the outside stations. Also, are there specific points I should pay attention to before buying the car, or is it enough to just take it straight to an inspection?

トルコ語から翻訳

You can charge at all AC charging stations, but unless you charge at home, in my opinion there's not much point - outside, it only fully charges from empty in 3-4 hours. It's the same from a regular home outlet, but some friends mentioned a device that can fully charge it in 1 hour when used. Or you can charge it via the engine using the E-Save feature. But still, I think this is a car made to be charged at home.

トルコ語から翻訳

Getting it into a detailed inspection is enough - it's important to check the engine and the underbody. For example, our car had an oil leak from underneath, so the seller gave a discount because of it, and we just went to the authorized service and got it easily sorted under warranty.

トルコ語から翻訳

I haven't seen anyone run into a major fault with this car, and hopefully I won't either. But generally the complaints about the Tonale are issues caused by misalignment at the joints between parts. For example trim noises appearing. Or, as I just said, oil leaking from the joint between two parts in the underbody, etc. Since the electric motor is mostly used in the city, I don't think the petrol engine will be under much load.

トルコ語から翻訳

Since the diesel engine is really low on performance I considered the 1.3, but like you said it doesn't make sense for me. I'm also worried the 1.5s might cause problems, but honestly I'm really torn between choosing the 1.6 diesel or the 1.5 hybrid.

トルコ語から翻訳

Let me tell you the pros and cons of both as far as I know. The 1.5's advantage is that it's performance-oriented, hybrid, and quieter than a diesel. Its disadvantages are that it can shift roughly when switching between the hybrid motor and the petrol engine and when changing gears. The 1.6's advantage is having a more well-known engine, and naturally a slightly better resale market. Its disadvantages are that it's not as powerful as other models, it runs noisily, and in cities with heavy traffic the transmission can overheat.

トルコ語から翻訳

Let me also say this - the 1.5 hybrid engine actually isn't that unknown of an engine. This engine is used in some Jeep models, even in the Egea Cross. Don't let the issues I've written scare you off - these are things that can happen in almost any car, and in a well-equipped car like the Tonale they can even be considered minor. I'm just trying to pass on what I know. By the way, their fuel figures are apparently close to each other.

トルコ語から翻訳

If you find a nice, accident-free car under warranty, no matter which model it is, I don't think it will let you down - you also have the authorized service assurance.

トルコ語から翻訳